|
|
||||||||
1 Laboratoire de Physiologie des Régulations Energétiques, Cellulaires et Moléculaires, Unité Mixte de Recherches 5578 Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique-Université Claude Bernard Lyon I, Laboratoire Associé Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, 69622 Villeurbanne, France; and 2 Division of Biochemistry, Faculty of Medicine and Pharmacy, University of Tasmania, Hobart, Australia 7001
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Endocrine
stimulation of muscle nonshivering thermogenesis (NST) in ducklings was
investigated in vitro using a perfused hindlimb preparation maintained
at 25°C. Effects of flow rate, norepinephrine (NE), epinephrine,
and glucagon on perfused muscle oxygen consumption (
O2)
and perfusion pressure were studied. Control ducklings (Cairina
moschata, 5 wk old) reared at
thermoneutrality (25°C, TN) were compared with two age-matched
groups exhibiting muscle NST in vivo: cold-acclimated ducklings
(4°C, 4 wk, CA) and glucagon-treated ducklings (103 nmol/kg twice
daily, intraperitoneally, GT). Basal
O2
was higher in CA than in TN or GT ducklings and increased in all groups
with elevated flow rates. Catecholamines increased both
O2
and perfusion pressure. The maximal effect on
O2
was higher in CA (+36%) and GT ducklings (+43%) than in controls
(+31%), but was associated with reduced vasoconstriction. Flow rate
did not consistently potentiate the NE response. At high doses,
catecholamines became inhibitory on
O2
while a monotonous increase of pressure was still observed. Glucagon,
by contrast, slightly decreased both
O2
and pressure. This vasodilatory effect was greater in CA ducklings than
controls in preconstricted preparations. In vivo, low-dose epinephrine
induced a modest thermogenic effect (+10%) in CA ducklings. These
findings showed that duckling muscle thermogenesis is directly
stimulated in vitro by catecholamines but not by glucagon. Higher in
vitro thermogenic effects of NE in ducklings that were expected to
exhibit muscle NST in vivo suggests catecholamine involvement in muscle
NST in vivo. Potential vascular control of avian muscle NST is
discussed.
catecholamines; cold acclimation; glucagon; vasoactivity
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
NONSHIVERING THERMOGENESIS (NST) is a common adaptive response to cold found in a number of mammalian species (9) and a few species of birds, including chickens, ducklings, and penguins (2, 13, 19). However, the sites and mechanisms of NST appear to differ in these classes. Brown adipose tissue (BAT) is well known to account for a large proportion of mammalian NST, whereas skeletal muscle is the main site of NST in ducklings (12). BAT thermogenesis is based on an uncoupling of the mitochondrial respiratory chain by the proton-translocator uncoupling protein (28). By contrast, avian mitochondria contain no mammalian-like uncoupling protein (29). Proposed mechanisms for avian NST include those based on fatty acid-induced loose-coupling of mitochondrial respiration (5) and also increased Ca2+ cycling by the sarcoplasmic reticulum (17). Although the sympathetic control of BAT NST is well documented, far less is known about the endocrine control of avian muscle NST.
On the basis of its marked thermogenic and lipolytic effects in birds (3, 4, 6, 14), glucagon appears as a potential mediator of avian NST. Moreover, plasma glucagon concentration is increased in cold-acclimated ducklings (4), and chronic administration of glucagon to ducklings kept at thermoneutrality leads to the development of NST (3). It was postulated that glucagon may trigger muscle NST by stimulating the release of fatty acids from a multilocular adipose tissue differentiated for lipolytic activity (2). Released fatty acids may then affect the respiration of muscle mitochondria, which show a higher basal metabolic rate (MR) and a higher increase in respiration due to the uncoupling effect of fatty acids after cold acclimation (5). As reflected by in vivo measurements of muscle blood flow and arteriovenous differences in oxygen content, muscle NST can be stimulated by exogenous glucagon (14). However, whether the action of glucagon is indirect through lipolysis or direct on myocytes cannot be inferred from these experiments. Besides the action of glucagon, other hormones such as catecholamines could also play a part in the stimulation of avian NST on account of some thermogenic effects of these hormones in birds, both in vivo (6, 24, 31) and in vitro (25). However, such calorigenic action is not invariably found (9) and is much lower than the calorigenic action of glucagon (6).
The use of in vitro perfused muscle preparations has provided numerous insights to the humoral control of muscle metabolism in mammals (reviewed in Ref. 26). Extended studies with perfused hindlimbs in rats have underlined the major role of catecholamines and vasoconstrictors in the modulation of muscle oxygen consumption (11). Recently, with the use of a perfused leg muscle preparation, it has been shown that catecholamines in interaction with glucagon could be potent stimulators of muscle resting oxygen uptake in chickens reared at thermoneutrality (18). It is, however, yet to be established whether this effect is potentiated in animals developing NST and is thus of adaptive interest.
The aim of this experiment was therefore to develop a perfused muscle preparation in ducklings allowing us to address the hypothesis that muscle thermogenesis is under direct hormonal control. Potential thermogenic and vascular effects of catecholamines and glucagon have been investigated in control ducklings reared at thermoneutrality (TN), and also in cold-acclimated (CA) and glucagon-treated (GT) ducklings, the latter two groups of animals showing muscle NST in vivo. Possible calorigenic effects of epinephrine were also investigated in vivo.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Animals. Male Muscovy ducklings (Cairina moschata L, pedigree R31, Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique) were obtained from a commercial stock breeder (Ets Grimaud). They were fed a commercial mash (Aliment Genthon Démarrage) ad libitum and had free access to water. Ducklings were kept in a constant photoperiod (8:16-h light-dark cycle). The cold-acclimation schedule described by Barré et al. (2) was used: from the age of 1 wk, ducklings were caged in groups of six for a period of 4 wk at either 4°C ambient temperature (Ta) (CA) or 25°C Ta (TN). The glucagon treatment schedule described by Barré et al. (3) was used. From the age of 1 wk, ducklings were caged in groups of six for a period of 4 wk at 25°C Ta and received twice daily an intraperitoneal injection of glucagon (103 nmol/kg; GT).
To standardize the basal values of oxygen consumption and perfusion pressure among the three groups, animals were kept at thermoneutrality (25°C) for 2 h before the start of the surgery.
Birds were cared for under the French Code of Practice for the Care and Use of Animals for Scientific Purposes, and the experimental protocols were approved by the French Ministry of Agriculture Ethics Committee (Animals).
Muscle preparation. The duckling limb surgical preparation was derived from that described by Eldershaw et al. (18) on chicken. Ducklings were anesthetized by continuous halothane inhalation. The left lower limb was surgically isolated and perfused. The major skin vessels were ligated, and the skin covering the limb was carefully removed. A prior intracardiac injection of heparin (2,000 U/kg) prevented blood coagulation during catheterization and the subsequent replacement of blood with artificial perfusate. The popliteal fossa was incised to expose the popliteal artery and vein. The popliteal nerve was divided and the hamstring muscles were ligated and resected proximal to the fossa to give good access for cannulation of the popliteal artery and vein with a polyethylene tubing (1.2 mm ID) filled with heparinized saline. To prevent flow to other tissues, tight ligatures were placed around the ankle and thigh, just above the cannulation site. The duckling was killed with an intracardiac injection of a lethal dose of pentobarbital. The arterial catheter was immediately connected to the perfusion open circuit. The entire surgical procedure routinely lasted ~30 min. During perfusion, the animal was laid on its back and the limb was supported partially aloft. Exposed muscle was covered in plastic cling wrap. After the perfusion had started, the contralateral limb was ligated similarly and excised. The muscles were removed and weighed to allow calculation of required perfusate flow to the perfused limb. This method of estimating perfused muscle mass was validated by infusing 1% Evans blue dye with the perfusate, followed by removal and weighing of stained muscle to determine the mass of muscle perfused, generally in the range of 23-27 g.
Perfusion
system. The perfusion system was
similar to that described previously (18). Briefly, it consisted of a
nonrecirculating constant flow system thermostated at 25°C to
ensure adequate oxygenation without the use of red blood cells. A
Krebs-Henseleit buffer was used as the perfusion medium, with a
composition of (in mM) 120 NaCl; 4.8 KCl; 1.2 KH2PO4;
1.2 MgSO4,
7H2O; 2.5 CaCl2; and 24 NaHCO3; this buffer contained 8.3 mM glucose and 2% bovine serum albumin (BSA), pH 7.4. Before use, the
perfusion medium was filtered (Millipore, 0.45 µm). The buffer was
continuously gassed with carbogen (95%
O2-5%
CO2) both in a reservoir placed
on ice and by passage through a Silastic tubing lung (5 m; 0.058 cm ID;
0.077 cm OD) before entering the limb muscles to ensure a constant high saturation of arterial O2 and
CO2. The whole circuit, which
consisted of a heat exchanger, bubble traps, and Silastic lung, was
placed in a 25°C thermostated water bath. A small mixing chamber,
placed on an electromagnetic stirrer, allowed the injection of hormones directly in the perfusate flow. Buffer solution was pumped from the
reservoir through the perfusion system and into the arterial catheter
by a Gilson peristaltic pump (Minipuls 8). An in-line pressure
transducer (PDCR 75 Nortek Bio 1000) was situated immediately upstream
from the arterial catheter. A mercury manometer was used to calibrate
the transducer at the start and at the end of a series of experiments.
The venous effluent flowed through a 1.5-ml thermostated chamber
(25°C) containing a Clark-type oxygen electrode connected to a
Gilson apparatus, and the effluent was discarded after measurement of
its oxygen partial pressure. The venous tubing and associated electrode
chamber did not exert any back pressure on the isolated muscle
preparation. The electrode was calibrated before and after each
experiment with gas mixture at 100% and 20.93% (atmospheric air) of
oxygen. Muscle O2 consumption
(
O2)
was calculated from arteriovenous difference in
O2 content and flow rate; the
oxygen dissolution Bunsen coefficient of
O2 in plasma was used. Where stated, infusions of hormones into the mixing chamber were made continuously at <1% of the total flow.
Flow
rate. Perfusions were conducted at
flow rates of either 0.33 ml · min
1 · g
1
(n = 5-6 per group) or 0.47 ml · min
1 · g
1
(n = 5 per group). The lower flow rate
was chosen to be within the range of average skeletal muscle blood flow
measured in vivo, whereas the higher rate corresponded to an increase
in flow equivalent to that seen in vivo after a glucagon injection to
the animal (14). The chosen flow rate remained constant throughout each experiment.
Hormone
infusion. The effects of infused
glucagon and catecholamines [norepinephrine (NE) and
epinephrine] were studied. Catecholamines were dissolved in
saline (9 g/l NaCl) containing 0.1% ascorbic acid. Solutions were
freshly prepared for each experiment. Glucagon solution (Novo-Nordisk)
also contained 107 mg lactose/mg glucagon. In each series of
experiments, infusion of vehicle alone had no effect on
O2
or perfusion pressure. Hormones were infused in the perfusate flow by a
precision peristaltic pump (Gilson minipuls). Final hormonal
concentrations tested were between 1 nM and 1 µM.
Muscle
metabolites. Muscle metabolite
concentrations were determined in limb muscle samples previously freeze
clamped with tongs precooled in liquid nitrogen. Samples were obtained
after 2 h of perfusion at 25°C at low (0.33 ml · min
1 · g
1)
or high (0.47 ml · min
1 · g
1)
flow rate with or without hormone stimulation (3-6 determinations per group). Frozen samples were stored at
80°C and powdered
under liquid nitrogen. Creatine phosphate, ATP, ADP, and AMP were
assayed by spectrophotometric methods. The values obtained with
perfused muscles in vitro were compared with in vivo data obtained from a separate batch of ducklings (n = 4-6 ducklings per group). These birds were catheterized (jugular
vein) 2 days before sampling under halothane anesthesia. At the time of
sampling, ducklings were placed in individual boxes and the catheter
was connected to polyethylene tubing. Animals were rested for 2 h and
were then anesthetized with 1 ml of pentobarbital sodium (50 mg/kg)
injected through the catheter without disturbing the animal.
Immediately after anesthesia, limb muscles were exposed and freeze
clamped. With this protocol, in vivo samples were obtained with minimal prior contraction of the sampled muscles.
Estimation of edema. Muscle samples were taken from the perfused limb after 2 h of perfusion (n = 3-6 values per group) or from the contralateral limb at the beginning of the experiment (denoted in vivo; n = 4-6 values per group). Samples were dried at 80°C to a constant weight. The ratio of fresh weight to dry weight was calculated from in vivo and perfused muscle samples to estimate the magnitude of edema after 2 h of perfusion with a 2% BSA buffer.
In
vivo
MR
measurement. MR was measured in vivo
by indirect calorimetry in an open circuit as described previously (2). To allow saline or epinephrine infusion, the jugular vein was cannulated under halothane anesthesia 2 days before the experiment. On
the day of the experiment, the vascular catheter was connected to a
continuous infusion pump (A99, Bioblock Scientific), and the bird was
positioned in the thermostatic chamber set at thermoneutrality (25°C). As performed with the protocol with perfused muscle in vitro, increasing hormone doses were tested successively in vivo after
a 120-min preliminary equilibration period. Each epinephrine infusion
lasted 20 min and was followed by a 40-min recovery period. MR was
monitored throughout. Total doses (and infusion rates) of epinephrine
bitartrate salt were 2 µg/kg (100 ng · kg
1 · min
1),
20 µg/kg (1 µg · kg
1 · min
1),
and 100 µg/kg (5 µg · kg
1 · min
1),
thus in the range of 6-300 nmol/kg. Epinephrine solutions were freshly prepared immediately before infusion. In vivo experiments were
performed with TN (n = 8) and CA
(n = 5 or 6) ducklings. Epinephrine
was chosen because this hormone induced a higher thermogenic effect
than NE in king penguin chicks in vivo (6).
Statistics. Values are presented as means ± SE. Statistical significance of observed variations was assessed by the one-factor analysis of variance (ANOVA) for repeated measures; observed differences between means were then tested by Scheffé's F test. Differences between values from the same group were assessed by Student's paired t-tests. The three-factors ANOVA (hormone concentration × group × flow rate) was reduced to only two factors by calculating the integrated response for the entire range of concentrations tested (area under the curve); a two-way ANOVA was then used. Statistical significance was recognized at P < 0.05.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Characterization of the perfused muscle preparation. Evans blue dye (1%) was routinely infused at the end of perfusion through the arterial catheter to assess the degree of perfusion of the preparation. The resultant staining confirmed that perfusate flow was confined to the lower limb in both hormone-stimulated and nonstimulated preparations. More than 98% of the isolated muscle tissue was actually perfused in this model.
Muscle wet weight-to-dry weight ratio (Table 1) was not different among the three in vivo groups, and no significant change occurred after perfusion at a low flow rate. At the high flow rate, the ratio slightly increased, indicating some edema formation in both TN and CA groups after >2 h of perfusion at this flow rate.
|
Muscle phosphagen concentrations (Table 1) were no different from in
vivo levels after 2 h of perfusion at the low (0.33 ml · min
1 · g
1)
or high (0.47 ml · min
1 · g
1)
flow rate without hormonal stimulation. Muscle energy charge of the
adenylate system, defined as ([ATP] + 0.5 × [ADP])/([ATP] + [ADP] + [AMP]), where brackets indicate concentration, remained at
the in vivo value regardless of the perfusion flow rates. Muscle phosphagens concentrations and energy charge were also
maintained at the in vivo levels after perfusion with
hormonal stimulation. A slight increase in the wet weight-to-dry weight
ratio was, however, noted after very high doses of catecholamines.
Basal values of
O2
and perfusion pressure.
At the low perfusion rate, basal
O2
was higher in CA (10.1 ± 0.4 µmol · g
1 · h
1,
P < 0.01) than in TN (8.1 ± 0.4 µmol · g
1 · h
1)
and GT (8.5 ± 0.3 µmol · g
1 · h
1)
ducklings (Table 2). Yet the difference
between CA and TN ducklings was not significant at the high perfusion
flow rate. A significant group effect
(P < 0.05) was also observed at low
flow rate on basal perfusion pressure, which was higher in TN (43.8 ± 1.6 mmHg) than in CA (35.8 ± 1.1 mmHg) and GT (31.3 ± 1.3 mmHg)
ducklings (P < 0.05 in each case).
The difference in pressure persisted at the high perfusion flow rate
between TN (53.1 ± 2.9 mmHg) and CA (41.3 ± 2.3 mmHg) ducklings
(P < 0.05).
|
O2
of TN and CA ducklings (Table 2). An increase in perfusion flow rate
induced an increase in
O2
(+32% in TN and +20% in CA ducklings,
P < 0.05). The flow effect was
therefore slightly more marked in TN than in CA ducklings, leading to a
nonsignificant difference in basal
O2
between groups at the high flow rate. The higher flow also induced an
increase in perfusion pressure (P < 0.05) in both groups of animals (+21% in TN and +15% in CA animals).
At both flow rates and after 30-40 min of stabilization, values of
O2
and pressure remained constant during perfusions without hormone
stimulation.
NE effects on
O2
and perfusion pressure.
Increasing concentrations of NE, including 1, 10, 20, 50, and 300 nM
and 1 µM, were tested. Regardless of prior treatment or flow rate, NE
infusion induced a rapid increase in perfusion pressure as well as a
rapid decrease in venous PO2 (Fig. 1), indicating a rapid onset of
vasoconstriction and an increase in
O2.
Effects were sustained throughout the period of NE infusion and were
rapidly reversed on cessation of NE infusion. Dose-curve responses for
both
O2
and perfusion pressure are shown in Fig. 2.
In all treatment groups, NE induced significant increases in
O2
and perfusion pressure at concentrations higher than 1 nM (P < 0.05). Effects on
O2
were higher in CA and GT ducklings than in TN controls, whereas effects
on perfusion pressure were lower. The maximal NE-stimulated increase in
O2
at the low flow was 2.5 µmol · g
1 · h
1
in TN (+31% over basal), 3.6 µmol · g
1 · h
1
in CA (+36% over basal), and 3.7 µmol · g
1 · h
1
in GT ducklings (+43% over basal). At higher doses of infused NE
(>300 nM),
O2
tended to decrease. The inhibitory effect of high doses of NE was,
however, much more marked at the high flow rate,
O2
being significantly decreased in TN ducklings
(P < 0.05), whereas it was still
increased (+35%) in CA ducklings. In TN animals, the
O2
obtained with the highest dose of NE was not significantly different
from the basal value without hormone stimulation. This was despite a
dose-dependent continuous increase in perfusion pressure. Perfusion
pressures associated with maximal
O2
effects at the low flow rate tended to be higher in TN (+330%) than in
CA (+280%) and GT (+260%, P < 0.05) ducklings. Similar trends were observed at the high flow rate.
There was a trend for half-maximal effective concentration values to be
lower in CA and GT ducklings (3.6 ± 1.7 and 4.1 ± 1.4 nM,
respectively) than in TN controls (13.5 ± 1.5 nM).
|
|
O2
and perfusion pressure. The overall NE-induced increase in
O2
was higher in CA ducklings (+136% at the high flow rate,
P < 0.05) and in GT ducklings
(+129% at the low flow rate, P < 0.05) than in TN ducklings. Similar results were observed when only the
1- to 10-nM range of NE concentrations was considered (+176% in CA and
+157% in GT ducklings, P < 0.05 in
each case).
|
O2
increase was similar at both rates, indicating that flow did not
potentiate the effect of NE.
Over the entire range of NE doses, the increase in perfusion pressure
was lower in CA (high flow,
44%,
P < 0.05) and GT (low flow,
43%, P < 0.05) than in
TN ducklings. Increases in perfusion pressure were not significantly
different in the 1- to 10-nM range of NE concentrations.
Effects of increasing doses of epinephrine (1 nM-1 µM) on
O2
and vasoconstriction in TN (n = 4) and
CA (n = 4) ducklings were similar to
those observed using NE, with peak values of
O2 obtained at 100 nM and reaching +1.9
µmol · g
1 · h
1
in TN (+20% over basal) and +2.9
µmol · g
1 · h
1
in CA (+28% over basal) ducklings (data not shown). The integrated
O2
response in the 1- to 10-nM range was higher in CA than in TN ducklings
(+157%). Higher epinephrine concentrations (>100 nM) were clearly
inhibitory, with values at 1 µM being not significantly different
from basal levels.
Glucagon effects on
O2
and perfusion pressure.
Increasing concentrations of glucagon (0, 1, 10, and 100 nM and 1 µM)
were tested on perfused muscles of TN, CA, and GT ducklings (Fig.
4, low flow only). In TN and CA groups,
experiments were conducted at the low and high (data not shown) flow
rates. After glucagon infusion, a decrease in perfusion pressure was
associated with an increase in venous
PO2, indicating some vasodilation and
a decrease in basal
O2.
These effects were usually significant for glucagon concentrations
>10 nM (P < 0.05); the decreases
in
O2
and perfusion pressure were then proportional to the glucagon concentration tested. The lack of direct thermogenic effect of glucagon
was not due to the low perfusion temperature (25°C), because
perfusion experiments performed at 40°C showed similar results
(data not shown).
|
O2
after the infusion of increasing concentrations of glucagon was not
different in absolute values from one group of animals to the other
whatever the perfusion flow rate. By contrast, the decrease in
perfusion pressure was more marked when the initial pressure was higher
and thus more marked in the TN groups at high (
15%) and low
(
12%) flow rate, whereas the decreases were less marked in the
CA and GT groups (
2 to
7%)
There was no significant effect of flow rate on the decrease in
O2
caused by glucagon in both TN and CA groups. However, in TN ducklings,
the decrease in pressure induced by glucagon was significantly more
marked at the high perfusion flow rate (P < 0.05).
Glucagon
effects
on a
preconstricted
muscle. The rather small effects of
glucagon on basal values of pressure could be due to the fact that
muscle preparations were nearly fully vasodilated. Perfused skeletal
muscles of TN and CA ducklings were thus preconstricted with 100 nM NE,
and the effects of glucagon were tested. Glucagon-induced vasodilation
increased with increasing concentrations of the peptide (Fig.
5) and was slightly more marked in CA than
in TN ducklings (P < 0.05) with 100 nM glucagon. These effects were nevertheless small compared with the
effects of the nitrodilator sodium nitroprusside (0.5 mM), which
abolished most of the NE-induced rise in pressure (
75% in TN
and
91% in CA), with values becoming not significantly different from the basal without NE. Glucagon had no significant effect
on NE-induced
O2,
whereas nitroprusside removed most of the effects of NE in TN
(
83%) but not in CA ducklings (
68%), in which the
O2
value remained higher (P < 0.05)
than the basal.
|
1 · kg
1,
P < 0.05) 10 min after the end of
the infusion. In CA ducklings, by contrast, low-dose epinephrine
induced a modest but significant increase in MR 10 min after the start
of the perfusion, with a peak at 7.5 W/kg (+0.6 W/kg, i.e., +10%,
P < 0.05). Increasing the dose of
epinephrine did not enhance the response, and at the highest dose, a
biphasic response started to appear with no stimulation during the
perfusion but a rise in MR afterward.
|
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The present study has investigated for the first time the endocrine control of resting muscle thermogenesis in ducklings. It has been demonstrated that perfusion flow rate and catecholamines can directly stimulate muscle thermogenesis in vitro. Furthermore, the thermogenic effect of catecholamines on perfused muscles in vitro was enhanced in CA and GT ducklings, two groups exhibiting regulatory muscle NST in vivo (2, 3, 12, 14). By contrast, glucagon had no direct thermogenic effect on perfused muscle in vitro. Finally, epinephrine at low doses exerted a small thermogenic effect in vivo in CA ducklings.
Validation of the perfused limb muscle preparation in
ducklings. In the present study, the lower limb
perfusion preparation originally described in the chicken (18) was
successfully applied to ducklings. Perfusions were performed at
25°C to avoid the need for erythrocytes in the perfusate but to
allow delivery of sufficient oxygen to the preparation, which was
stable with respect to basal
O2,
basal perfusion pressure, and high energy phosphate levels throughout
the experimental period. Similar studies of muscle metabolism with
perfused or incubated mammalian muscle preparations at 25°C gave
similar results, with a correction factor, to those performed at
37°C (8, 11). The lower flow rate of 0.33 ml · min
1 · g
wet wt
1 of muscle in the
popliteal bed was chosen according to microsphere studies of blood flow
in birds (12). At this flow rate, the venous
PO2 did not fall below 200 mmHg, and
muscle phosphagen levels were maintained at their in vivo levels. The
energy charge was consequently well preserved, and no effect of
increased flow rate on phosphagen levels was observed. Because of the
absence of edema development at this low flow rate even after long
perfusions, Krebs buffer containing 2% BSA appears to be a suitable
perfusate for duckling muscle at low temperatures. At the higher flow
rate or after high doses of catecholamines, a slight edema was observed especially in TN ducklings, but similar degrees of edema
were reported by others in perfused rat muscles (10). However, this did
not cause any rise in basal perfusion pressure over time. The lower
vascular resistance of CA and GT ducklings could be partly accounted
for by a higher vascular density than in TN animals (15).
Basal values of
O2.
The oxygen consumption of resting perfused muscles in TN duckling at
25°C (8.1 ± 0.4 µmol · g
1 · h
1)
is similar to that measured in the chicken in the same conditions (7.4 ± 0.3 µmol · g
1 · h
1,
Ref. 18). Limb muscles of CA ducklings showed a higher basal
O2
than those of TN ducklings (+25%), although all animals had been
submitted to a 2-h fast at thermoneutrality before the surgical preparation. Similarly, the
O2
of incubated skeletal muscle slices from CA sparrows was higher than in
controls (1). An increased basal
O2
was also noted in incubated muscles of CA pigs (23), a large mammal
devoid of BAT. By contrast, such a difference was not observed with
perfused muscles of CA and TN rats (21, 30). This higher basal
O2
of CA vs. TN ducklings could contribute to the higher resting MR
measured in vivo at thermoneutrality (Ref. 2 and the present study). It
may involve stimulations of several ion-transport mechanisms, such as
the membrane
Na+-K+-adenosinetriphosphatase
(ATPase) activity, as shown in muscles of CA pigs (23), or the
sarcoplasmic reticulum
Ca2+-ATPase, as demonstrated in
muscles of CA ducklings (17). Furthermore, it is in agreement with the
increase in mitochondrial basal respiration observed in CA ducklings
(5).
O2.
Certainly, in whole body studies there is an absence of effect of this
treatment on the resting MR measured 24 h after the last injection of
glucagon (3). In GT ducklings, exogenous glucagon is required to
stimulate muscle NST (3, 14).
Flow-induced increase in
O2.
An increase in the perfusion flow rate, within limits compatible with
physiological variations, entailed an increase in
O2. It was not caused by an hypoperfusion at the low flow rate because no
change in phosphagen levels was induced by the increase in flow, levels
remaining similar to those measured in vivo. This phenomenon has
already been observed in several perfused muscle preparations in rats
and dogs (Ref. 10; review in Ref. 11). This flow-limited
O2 uptake can therefore be
extended to bird muscles, as shown in ducklings (this study) and in
chickens (18). The relationship between
O2
and perfusion flow could be interpreted as a physiological limitation
of
O2
at rest by O2 supply (10). Such a
phenomenon could possibly account for the heterogeneity of perfusion
observed in mammalian muscle at rest, possibly involving vasomotion in
terminal arterioles (16). This does not mean that the muscle is
hypoxic, because a marked decrease in phosphocreatine concentration
should be observed under such circumstances. Heterogeneous perfusion of
muscle has, however, not been reported, to our knowledge, in bird
muscles. Other mechanisms could also be involved in the flow-induced
O2.
Given the link between the increase in
O2 and the rise in perfusion pressure, a direct role of the smooth muscle
cells of the vascular network has been suggested (11). Although the
contribution of the vascular cell
O2 uptake to total
O2
remains to be fully evaluated, it can be noted that the lower flow-induced rise in basal
O2
of CA ducklings was accompanied by a lower rise in perfusion pressure.
Alternatively, shear stress-dependent release of autacoids by
endothelial cells might have a role in a paracrine control of skeletal
muscle metabolism (11). The respective contribution, if any, of these
different mechanisms remains unclear.
O2
and vasoconstriction. The dose-response curve over the full
concentration range was biphasic, catecholamines stimulating
O2
at low concentrations (<100 nM) but tending to inhibit
O2
at high concentrations (>100 nM). Similar results were obtained after
NE infusion in perfused chicken (18) or rat hindlimb (11, 31). The
maximal NE-induced increase in
O2
in TN ducklings (+31% over the basal) may be compared with that
observed in chickens (+35% over the basal, Ref. 18) and in the rat
hindlimb (+60-80%, Refs. 11 and 21). It should be noted that a
thermogenic effect of catecholamines in vitro was observed in both
constant-flow (11, 30) and constant-pressure (33) perfusions of rat
hindlimb. There was no consistent potentiating effect of flow rate on
the NE effect in duckling limb muscles, in agreement with the results
obtained on rat hindlimb muscles (reviewed in Ref. 11).
The thermogenic effect of NE was observed both at low (1-10 nM)
and high doses (
100 nM). Low doses are within the physiological circulating levels of hormones observed in birds (22), whereas the high
doses may reflect those occurring at sympathetic synapses (reviewed in
Ref. 11). Local concentrations near sympathetic nerve terminals may
indeed be significantly higher than reported plasma values.
Furthermore, some authors have underlined similarities between high NE
concentrations (
100 nM) and high-frequency sympathetic nerve
stimulation (>4 Hz) effects on perfused muscle
O2
and associated perfusion pressure (11). Because skeletal muscle sympathetic nerve activity is stimulated in cold-exposed redpolls (27),
high NE concentrations may be reached in skeletal muscles and could
play a role in the control of muscle thermogenesis.
Possible involvement of catecholamines in the control
of muscle NST. Cold acclimation and chronic glucagon
treatment, two treatments inducing duckling muscle NST in vivo (2, 3,
12, 14), were associated with increased thermogenic response to NE.
Such a potentiating effect of cold acclimation was not found in rats by
Grubb and Folk (21), whereas a marked increase in the thermogenic
effect of NE was observed in perfused muscles of CA rats by Shiota and
Masumi (30). Contrary to the rat model, in the duckling hindlimb the
NE-induced increase in
O2
cannot be due to the presence of diffuse BAT depots in the preparation, because thermogenic BAT is absent in birds (2, 29).
A thermogenic effect of NE at the muscle level in vitro suggests that
catecholamines have the potential to mediate some thermogenic effect in
vivo. Present results show that epinephrine at low dose exerted a small
(+10%) but significant thermogenic effect in CA ducklings. Thermogenic
responses to catecholamines in birds in vivo have been sparsely
reported with values reaching +10-40% over basal MR (6, 24, 31).
Furthermore, a higher thermogenic response to NE was reported in CA
than in warm-acclimated pigeons (24). This is in keeping with
observations that plasma catecholamine concentrations is higher in CA
than in TN birds (see Ref. 6 for references) and that the sympathetic
nervous system is activated in cold-exposed birds, as demonstrated by
an increased tissue NE turnover (27). However, it contrasts with many
studies that did not find any thermogenic effect of catecholamines in
birds (reviewed in Ref. 9). Such discrepancy could result from
differences between species or from the use of high concentrations of
hormone resulting in responses corresponding to the inhibitory part of the in vitro dose-response curve associated with excessive
vasoconstriction. Present results indeed indicate that the response to
epinephrine in vivo depends on the cold-acclimation status of the bird
and the dose used. At the high dose, the biphasic response, which is
similar to that observed with catecholamines in penguins (6), suggests
that the thermogenic effect of catecholamines in birds in vivo may be
limited by their vasomotor action. The potential for
catecholamine-induced muscle NST shown in vitro may therefore be
expressed in vivo when their vasomotor action is reduced, such as in CA
ducklings.
In the present experiments, high concentrations of catecholamines
decreased
O2
in constant-flow perfused duckling limb, especially in TN animals. Such
inhibition was not observed in CA and GT ducklings, possibly because of
a lower increase in perfusion pressure. An extended resistance capacity
to vasoconstrictive and thermogenic effects of high doses of NE has
also been reported in the hindlimb of CA rats (21). It is therefore
possible that the inhibiting effect on
O2
of high doses of NE in TN ducklings is related to the marked
vasoconstriction observed, somehow creating functional arteriovenous
shunts in the absence of anatomically identified shunts (11). Similar
pressure-related shunts have been suggested in rat hindlimb infused
with serotonin or with high doses NE (11).
The higher thermogenic effect of NE in vitro in ducklings that display
muscle NST in vivo suggests a possible key role of catecholamines in
the activation of muscle NST in vivo. It should, however, be noted that
the catecholamine-induced thermogenic effect in vivo in CA ducklings is
rather modest (+10%) as compared with the potential for NST estimated
in vivo (+71%) by simultaneous measurements of MR and
electromyographic activity in cold-exposed CA ducklings (2). Clearly,
NST induced by exogenous infusion of catecholamines does not reach the
magnitude of cold-induced muscle NST. A similar conclusion was pointed
out previously with glucagon-induced calorigenic effect, which cannot
account for the entire cold-induced NST (14). It is therefore possible
that several factors are acting together in vivo to activate muscle NST.
Glucagon effects on
O2
and perfusion pressure.
On the basis that the higher muscle thermogenic response to
catecholamines observed after cold acclimation was reproduced by the
chronic administration of glucagon at thermoneutrality (GT ducklings),
the present results support assertions that glucagon may play a major
role in the long-term development of muscle NST in birds (3, 6). This
is in keeping with other results obtained in vivo suggesting that
glucagon could be a potential mediator of avian muscle NST (3, 6, 14).
It was, however, not known whether the short-term thermogenic effect of
glucagon was direct on skeletal muscle cells or mediated indirectly for
instance by the release of endogenous stimulators such as fatty acids.
O2.
In fact, with the constant-flow perfusion system used, glucagon alone
acted to decrease basal
O2
in all treatment groups. Because glucagon also showed vasodilatory effect, this hormone is thus acting in a fashion similar to most other
vasodilators, i.e., by decreasing the
O2
of constant flow-perfused muscles, possibly by dilating nonnutritive
vessels to increase perfusion heterogeneity (11). This effect, which
was low on basal perfusion pressure, presumably because the limb was
virtually fully dilated, was enhanced in an NE-preconstricted
preparation, especially in CA ducklings. In these experimental
conditions, the vasodilatory effect of glucagon differed from that
obtained with nitroprusside because it was not accompanied by a drop in
O2,
suggesting that glucagon also affects nutritive flow.
The present results therefore indicate that the action of glucagon as a
potential mediator of muscle NST is likely to be indirect, possibly via
its vasomotor, metabolic, and neurogenic actions. The vasodilatory
effect of glucagon may stimulate
O2
in vivo. Indeed, because glucagon both increases cardiac output in the whole animal (14) and induces a concomitant relaxation of blood vessels
(present study), it would cause increased flow to skeletal muscles.
Such a rise in muscle blood flow after glucagon has already been
measured using the microsphere technique (14), and the present results
show that an increased flow to skeletal muscle increases
O2
(Table 2). It is, however, likely that this effect does not account for
the entire glucagon-induced thermogenesis observed in vivo.
Alternatively, the vasodilatory effects of glucagon may act to
potentiate the thermogenic effects of endogenous catecholamines by
lowering the detrimental effects of vasoconstriction (18). Besides its cardiovascular effects, glucagon has also marked effects on
the mobilization of lipids and carbohydrates, which could possibly modulate muscle thermogenesis. Finally, recent data from this laboratory have shown that glucagon injection stimulates the endogenous release of catecholamines in ducklings (Y. Filali-Zagzouti, H. Abdelmelek, J.-R. Pequignot, and H. Barré, unpublished
data), suggesting that part of the glucagon effect in vivo
may be mediated by catecholamines. This is in keeping with an
activation of muscle sympathetic nerve activity, which has already been
shown in man (32). Clarification of these different possibilities
obviously deserves investigation.
Possible involvement of the vascular system in muscle
metabolic responses. The observation of a thermogenic
effect of catecholamines in duckling muscles in vitro raises the
question of the possible mechanism involved. Although increased ion
cycling at the myocyte level has been suggested on account of the
inhibitory effect of ouabain on the NE-induced effect in CA rats (30),
no clear mechanism has emerged in mammals. It has, however, become
clear that the NE-induced muscle thermogenesis may involve a vascular
control of perfused muscle metabolism (11). This is based on the close relationship between O2 and
perfusion pressure observed in perfused rat muscle. In ducklings,
similar linear relationships were observed between changes in
O2
and increases in pressure at low doses of NE
(r = 0.6-0.8 in the three groups,
P < 0.05). However, increases in
O2
were greater in CA and GT ducklings, the groups exhibiting the lowest
increases in pressure. This result does not directly support a major
role for contracting vascular smooth muscle cells as the primary site
of O2 uptake (11), although any
such relationship is likely to be complex in perfused muscle
preparations. Vasoconstriction, however, does appear to have an
essential role in NE-induced
O2 because nitroprusside, a dilator specific to vascular smooth muscle, abolished the NE-induced rise in pressure and removed most of the
effects on
O2.
Similar results were also noted in rat and chicken perfused muscles
(11, 18). It has been proposed that the vascular system may act to
control the supply of nutrients to putative regions of increased
thermogenesis within the muscle (11). Although specialized
heat-producing muscle cells have been described in a modified eye
muscle of some fishes (7), no such specialization has been reported in
avian skeletal muscle. However, decreases in the coupling state of
mitochondria of the slow-twitch fiber types have been reported in
ducklings (15), suggesting increased thermogenic capacity of these
fibers. Interestingly, there is a higher density of resistance
arterioles in slow compared with fast mammalian muscles (reviewed in
Ref. 11), suggesting that flow to slow fibers might be more sensitive
to vascular effects. It should now be investigated whether
catecholamines induce a redistribution of perfusate flow in duckling
skeletal muscle and whether any such effect is altered by either cold
acclimation or glucagon treatment.
In conclusion, we have directly assessed the in vitro endocrine
modulation of muscle NST in ducklings by using a constant flow-perfused
preparation. Contrary to glucagon, catecholamines can stimulate muscle
thermogenesis in vitro, and the effect was enhanced after cold
acclimation. Long-term administration of glucagon to ducklings reared
at thermoneutrality reproduced the effects of cold acclimation, further
supporting a role for this peptide in the cold acclimation process in
birds. The higher thermogenic effect of NE in vitro in ducklings that
display muscle NST in vivo raises the possibility of catecholamine
involvement in activating this mechanism. A potential role of the
vasculature in the control of avian muscle NST is also suggested.
Perspectives
Present results shed new light on the endocrine modulation of muscle NST in birds and emphasize the potent role played by the vasculature in modulating
O2.
The implications of these in vitro data with respect to the in vivo
situation are unclear but raise the possibility that excessive
vasoconstriction may be detrimental to the thermogenic capacity of
skeletal muscle. This may be the reason why little if any
catecholamine-mediated thermogenic effect is observed in vivo in birds.
The potential for catecholamine-induced muscle NST as demonstrated in
vitro may be expressed in vivo when vasomotor action is reduced, such as in CA ducklings. In the rat, exercise capacity and muscle insulin sensitivity are also altered by vasomotion (reviewed in Ref. 11), suggesting that vasomotor modulation of muscle metabolism may be a
general phenomenon. The biochemical mechanism underlying catecholamine-induced thermogenesis in skeletal muscle is currently unclear. The thermogenic effects of catecholamines in duckling perfused
muscles (i.e., in animals devoid of BAT) do not support the possibility
that the similar results obtained in rats are related to the presence
of BAT in the preparation. Thus skeletal muscle itself may be a site of
catecholamine-induced thermogenesis. The recent discovery of a gene
closely related to uncoupling protein and expressed in rat skeletal
muscle (20) may be directly related to the observed regulatory
thermogenic capacity of this tissue. Consequently, the potential
presence of such a protein in birds, especially those exhibiting
skeletal muscle NST, should be investigated in an attempt to define a
mechanism for the thermogenic effect of catecholamines in skeletal
muscle.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
Authors are greatly indebted to M. G. Clark for helpful discussions and to E. Q. Colquhoun for invaluable help, suggestions, and discussions in setting up the perfused muscle preparation.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
This work was supported by grants from the Université Claude Bernard, the Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique (INRA), and the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS). F. Marmonier was in receipt of a Région Rhône-Alpes fellowship.
Address for reprint requests: C. Duchamp, Lab. Physiologie des Régulations Energétiques, Cellulaires et Moléculaires, UMR 5578 CNRS, LA INRA, Fac. Sciences, Bât 404, 4ème étage, 43 Bld 11 Novembre 1918, F-69622 Villeurbanne Cedex, France.
Received 13 August 1996; accepted in final form 3 July 1997.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1.
Barnett, L. B.
Seasonal changes in temperature acclimatization of the house sparrow.
Comp. Biochem. Physiol.
33:
559-578,
1970.
2.
Barré, H.,
F. Cohen-Adad,
C. Duchamp,
and
J.-L. Rouanet.
Multilocular adipocytes from Muscovy ducklings differentiated in response to cold acclimation.
J. Physiol. (Lond.)
375:
27-38,
1986
3.
Barré, H.,
F. Cohen-Adad,
and
J.-L. Rouanet.
Two daily glucagon injections induce nonshivering thermogenesis in Muscovy ducklings.
Am. J. Physiol.
252 (Endocrinol. Metab. 15):
E616-E620,
1987
4.
Barré, H.,
A. Geloen,
P. Mialhe,
and
J.-L. Rouanet.
Effect of glucagon on bird thermogenesis.
In: Endocrine Regulation as Adaptative Mechanisms to the Environment, edited by I. Assenmacher,
and J. Boissin. Paris: Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, 1986, p. 395-401.
5.
Barré, H.,
J. Nerdergaard,
and
B. Cannon.
Increased respiration in skeletal muscle mitochondria from cold-acclimated ducklings: uncoupling effects of free fatty acids.
Comp. Biochem. Physiol. B Biochem. Mol. Biol.
85:
343-348,
1986.
6.
Barré, H.,
and
J.-L. Rouanet.
Calorigenic effect of glucagon and catecholamines in king penguin chicks.
Am. J. Physiol.
244 (Regulatory Integrative Comp. Physiol. 13):
R758-R763,
1983
7.
Block, B. A.
Thermogenesis in muscle.
Annu. Rev. Physiol.
56:
535-577,
1994[Medline].
8.
Bonen, A.,
M. G. Clark,
and
E. J. Henriksen.
Experimental approaches in muscle metabolism: hindlimb perfusion and isolated muscle incubations.
Am. J. Physiol.
266 (Endocrinol. Metab. 29):
E1-E16,
1994
9.
Chaffee, R. R. J.,
and
J. C. Roberts.
Temperature acclimation in birds and mammals.
Annu. Rev. Physiol.
33:
155-202,
1971[Medline].
10.
Chinet, A. E.,
and
J. Mejsnar.
Is resting muscle oxygen uptake controlled by oxygen availability to cells?
J. Appl. Physiol.
66:
253-260,
1989
11.
Clark, M. G.,
E. Q. Colquhoun,
S. Rattigan,
K. A. Dora,
T. P. D. Eldershaw,
J. L. Hall,
and
J. Ye.
Vascular and endocrine control of muscle metabolism.
Am. J. Physiol.
268 (Endocrinol. Metab. 31):
E797-E812,
1995
12.
Duchamp, C.,
and
H. Barré.
Skeletal muscle as the major site of nonshivering thermogenesis in cold-acclimated ducklings.
Am. J. Physiol.
265 (Regulatory Integrative Comp. Physiol. 34):
R1076-R1083,
1993
13.
Duchamp, C.,
H. Barré,
G. Delage,
J.-L. Rouanet,
F. Cohen-Adad,
and
Y. Minaire.
Nonshivering thermogenesis and adaptation to fasting in king penguin chicks.
Am. J. Physiol.
257 (Regulatory Integrative Comp. Physiol. 26):
R744-R751,
1989
14.
Duchamp, C.,
J. Chatonnet,
A. Dittmar,
and
H. Barré.
Increased role of skeletal muscle in the calorigenic response to glucagon of cold-acclimated ducklings.
Am. J. Physiol.
265 (Regulatory Integrative Comp. Physiol. 34):
R1084-R1091,
1993
15.
Duchamp, C.,
F. Cohen-Adad,
J.-L. Rouanet,
and
H. Barré.
Histochemical arguments for muscular non-shivering thermogenesis in Muscovy ducklings.
J. Physiol. (Lond.)
457:
27-45,
1992
16.
Duling, B. R.,
and
D. H. Damon.
An examination of the measurement of flow heterogeneity in striated muscle.
Circ. Res.
60:
1-13,
1987
17.
Dumonteil, E.,
H. Barré,
and
G. Meissner.
Sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase and ryanodine receptor in cold-acclimated ducklings and thermogenesis.
Am. J. Physiol.
265 (Cell Physiol. 34):
C507-C513,
1993
18.
Eldershaw, T.,
C. Duchamp,
J. Ye,
M. G. Clark,
and
E. Q. Colquhoun.
Potential for nonshivering thermogenesis in perfused chicken (Gallus domesticus) muscle.
Comp. Biochem. Physiol.
117A:
545-554,
1997.
19.
El Halawani, M. E.,
O. W. Wilson,
and
R. E. Burger.
Cold-acclimation and the role of catecholamines in body temperature regulation in male leghorns.
Poult. Sci.
49:
621-632,
1970[Medline].
20.
Fleury, C.,
M. Neverova,
S. Collins,
S. Raimbault,
O. Champigny,
C. Levy-Meyrueis,
F. Bouillaud,
M. F. Seldin,
R. S. Surwit,
D. Ricquier,
and
C. H. Warden.
Uncoupling protein-2: a new thermogenic protein and a new gene linked to obesity and hyperinsulism.
Nat. Genet.
15:
269-272,
1997[Medline].
21.
Grubb, B.,
and
G. E. Folk.
Effect of cold acclimation on norepinephrine stimulated oxygen consumption in muscle.
J. Comp. Physiol.
110:
217-226,
1976.
22.
Hart, B.,
G. Stanford,
M. Ziegler,
C. Lake,
and
B. Chernow.
Catecholamines: study of interspecies variations.
Crit. Care Med.
17:
1203-1222,
1989[Medline].
23.
Herpin, P.,
B. W. McBride,
and
H. S. Bayley.
Effect of cold-exposure on energy metabolism in young pig.
Can. J. Physiol. Pharmacol.
65:
236-245,
1987[Medline].
24.
Hissa, R.,
A. Pyörnilä,
and
S. Saarela.
Effect of peripheral norepinephrine on thermoregulation in temperature-acclimated pigeon.
Comp. Biochem. Physiol. C Pharmacol. Toxicol. Endocrinol.
51:
243-247,
1975.
25.
Hissa, R.,
K. Rantala,
and
E. Jeronen.
Effect of norepinephrine on the oxygen uptake in vitro by the pigeon.
Gen. Pharmacol.
6:
303-307,
1975.
26.
Jansky, L.
Humoral thermogenesis and its role in maintaining energy balance.
Physiol. Rev.
75:
237-259,
1995
27.
Koban, M.,
and
D. D. Feist.
The effect of cold on norepinephrine turnover in tissues of seasonally acclimatized redpolls (Carduellis flammea).
J. Comp. Physiol.
146:
137-144,
1982.
28.
Nicholls, D. G.,
S. A. Cunningham,
and
E. Rial.
The bioenergetic mechanisms of brown adipose tissue mitochondria.
In: Brown Adipose Tissue, edited by P. Trayhurn,
and D. G. Nicholls. Baltimore, MD: Arnold, 1986, p. 52-85.
29.
Saarela, S.,
J. S. Keith,
E. Hohtola,
and
P. Trayhurn.
Is the "mammalian" brown fat-specific mitochondrial uncoupling protein present in adipose tissues of birds?
Comp. Biochem. Physiol. B Biochem. Mol. Biol.
100:
45-49,
1991.
30.
Shiota, M.,
and
S. Masumi.
Effect of norepinephrine on consumption of oxygen in perfused skeletal muscle from cold-exposed rats.
Am. J. Physiol.
254 (Endocrinol. Metab. 17):
E482-E489,
1988
31.
Sutter, G. C.,
and
R. A. MacArthur.
Beta-adrenergic sensitivity in juvenile American coots (Fulica americana): evidence of nonshivering thermogenesis.
Comp. Biochem. Physiol. C Pharmacol. Toxicol. Endocrinol.
93:
105-110,
1989.
32.
Takayama, S.,
Y. Nakajima,
S. Toma,
and
T. Sakamoto.
Increased muscle sympathetic nerve activity after glucagon administration in man.
J. Auton. Nerv. Syst.
54:
171-175,
1995[Medline].
33.
Ye, J.-M.,
M. G. Clark,
and
E. Q. Colquhoun.
Constant-pressure perfusion of rat hindlimb shows
- and
-adrenergic stimulation of oxygen consumption.
Am. J. Physiol.
269 (Endocrinol. Metab. 32):
E960-E968,
1995
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. E. Silva Thermogenic Mechanisms and Their Hormonal Regulation Physiol Rev, April 1, 2006; 86(2): 435 - 464. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
|